Banana Pudding

Members
  • Content Count

    211
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    2

Everything posted by Banana Pudding

  1. Do you even know which thread you're in? The title of the thread is "Los Santos Map Size". You linked to an individual post. That post answered nothing. Your post was a waste of space. This is what I want you to do: -List the names of all the people who have posted in the thread who have contributed anything about the size of Los Santos. -Look for your name on that list. You don't see it, do you? Go bother someone else. the helicopter screenshot covers : NW: north of Santa Monica (Ocean Towers) NE: Beverly Center and north-west of Downtown SE : Port of Long Beach (and maybe more to east) I'm not sure it goes that far north. I could have gone farther east though since I just included what was visible and not behind the buildings. If it covers as much area as you say, it would make Los Santos even smaller.
  2. It's over 3 times the area of IV's map. How big was SA compared to IV? I recommend reading the forums, not just posting incessantly in one topic. http://www.igta5.com...dpost__p__31543 1. My post is about the map size of this game. I don't care about which game has the biggest map. 2. The post you linked to doesn't answer my question.
  3. I'm not going to do all of the work on this one. I'll save some for you. Go look at my last post above this one... I don't know the exact fraction, but I don't really care. That area is roughly one-third of the map. Remember my helicopter comparison - http://i.imgur.com/B8jzy.jpg Notice that the sides got cut off a little on the IV pic, but the GTA V pic is at an angle which shows a lot more sky and significantly less land area - http://i.imgur.com/Rm05a.jpg Study those a little. How big does Los Santos look to you now? Convinced?
  4. I'm trying to figure out how much area the helicopter screenshot ( http://i.minus.com/ibnNnQJ1dZQOYR.jpg) covers on TreeFitty's map. Is this close?
  5. Let's see... You've got a dirt road next to a hill with a lot of green vegetation on it and then you have a hazy view of a liquor store. Nope. Not proof.
  6. Tried and failed would be more accurate. Lol how did I fail? You said that there were only hills countryside and beaches in the game when in the trailer there is a stretch of desert Well, you didn't prove that it's a desert. So, go ahead and submit your evidence.
  7. SD still fails the hills, countryside and beaches test so it's not in the game either. If you're allowed to widen the interpretation of hills, countryside and beaches, why not anything else? I'm not actually taking things too literally. I'm just explaining a point. I think SF and LV are still possible.
  8. Did you even read what I wrote? Okay, we'll do this slowly one question at a time... Is San Diego a hill, countryside or a beach? Yes or no.
  9. What you quoted is not from Rockstar. Read more below... You missed the point. The point is if San Diego is possible, then SF and LV are also possible. Mexico even becomes a possibility. Rockstar's quotes: If you take a strict interpretation of their words, no other city will be in the game. It would just be Los Santos. San Diego wouldn't be possible because it doesn't work with the first quote. It's not a hill, countryside or a beach. To allow San Diego means you're able to add things that don't fit within Rockstar's exact words. If you can do that, then you can add other things as well. There are 2 possibilities: 1. Los Santos is the only city. 2. All other cities can be included. P.S. San Diego would be a terrible city to add. It has nothing significant to offer that's not already in Los Angeles. Do you really want 2 similar cities?
  10. First, I don't believe they said LS would be the largest urban area. I don't think they mentioned anything like that. If you stick to exactly what they said - "the city of Los Santos and surrounding hills, countryside and beaches", then San Diego is out because San Diego isn't a hill, countryside or beach. If you disagree and think San Diego can be included even though it's not a hill, contryside or beach, then San Fierro and Las Venturas can be included since we're allowed to expand on what they said. Since San Diego can be a hill, countryside or beach, I say SF and LV can be part of southern California.
  11. No they didn't. They only confirmed one city. They didn't confirm there's only one city.
  12. I would need the game to do that. It's too hard to find good screenshots of the areas I would need and I would also need to know the exact position of those images on the map. You could do it. I'm not.
  13. me too I didn't estimate the whole map - just the city area that they showed in the trailer. There could be more city area to the east and southeast. Rockstar pretty much confirmed the map is at least bigger than IV's. Edit..... 1. I don't have those games. 2. LA Noire was set in the 1940's before the Bank Tower and Citigroup Center were built. I'm not sure about the other buildings and I don't feel like looking it up.
  14. Do you want to see something scary? I decided to estimate the smallest possible city area. Every point in my map ( http://i.imgur.com/2gypg.jpg ) would fit inside this area: It looks a little like Daffy Duck, doesn't it? But seriously, it would all fit in there. I don't think it's that small though. But it's possible.